| Platinum | Fritz's Frozen Custard |
| Gold | Andy's Frozen Custard |
| Silver | Baskin-Robbins |
| Bronze | Sweet Spot Cake Shoppe |
| Top Pick | CJ's Cool Treats |
| Top Pick | Clementine's |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | McDonald's |
| Top Pick | Silky's Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Udderly Moolicious |