| Platinum | O'Fallon Buick GMC |
| Gold | Sigmund Auto Service |
| Silver | Lasater Auto |
| Bronze | Len's Auto |
| Top Pick | Hillside Auto Repair |
| Top Pick | Jimmy's Automotive |
| Top Pick | Lens |
| Top Pick | One Stop Tire and Auto |
| Top Pick | Salt River Automotive |
| Top Pick | Sig's Automotive |