| Platinum | The Cookie Box |
| Gold | Grandmas Cookies |
| Silver | Crumbl Cookies - Cottleville |
| Bronze | Valenti Bakery & Deli |
| Top Pick | Goodcents Deli Fresh Subs |
| Top Pick | Hot Box Cookies |
| Top Pick | Nothing Bundt Cakes |
| Top Pick | Old Town Donut Shop |
| Top Pick | Sweet Spot Cake Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Twisted Sugar |