| Platinum | Cadence Academy Preschool |
| Gold | Amerikids Christian Center |
| Silver | ABC Daycare & Learning Center |
| Bronze | World of Little People |
| Top Pick | Just 4 Us Childcare |
| Top Pick | Kiddie Academy of O'Fallon |
| Top Pick | Kidsplay |
| Top Pick | Learning Lodge |
| Top Pick | Little Sunshine's Playhouse of Ofallon |
| Top Pick | Los Ninos Preschool & Child Cr |