| Platinum | Imo's Pizza |
| Gold | Pantera's Pizza |
| Silver | Stefanina's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | A'mis Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Good News Brewing Company & Wood Fired Pizza |
| Top Pick | JJ Twigs Pizza & Pub |
| Top Pick | Monicals Pizza of O'Fallon |
| Top Pick | Noto Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pirrone's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Plank Road Pizza |