| Platinum | Stefanina's Pizzeria |
| Gold | Fratelli's Ristorante |
| Silver | Massa's Italian Grille - Winghaven |
| Bronze | Pasta House Company |
| Top Pick | A'mis Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Clayton's |
| Top Pick | Erio's Ristorante |
| Top Pick | JJ Twigs Pizza & Pub |
| Top Pick | Madisons Cafe |