| Platinum | His and Hers BBQ |
| Gold | Heavy Smoke BBQ |
| Silver | Sugarfire Smoke House |
| Bronze | Salt and Smoke |
| Top Pick | Bandana's Bar-B-Q |
| Top Pick | Bandana's BBQ - Saint Peters |
| Top Pick | Dukes BBQ Shack |
| Top Pick | Lil Mickey's Memphis Barbeque |
| Top Pick | Pappy's Smokehouse St. Peters |
| Top Pick | The Mad Hatter |
